In Western countries, one of the overwhelming trends of the 20th Century was the dramatic increase in women's formal labour force participation. The drivers of that change have been both social and economic, but the role of technological change may be underappreciated. A new working paper by Myera Rashid (Northwestern University) focuses on the changes arising from the adoption of the typewriter. While that might not seem like an important technology to drive meaningful change, Rashid notes that:
Offices in the US adapted to the arrival of the commercial typewriter in the 1880s by shifting towards the available supply of educated women who provided cheaper labor: while women initially made up only 12 percent of the secretarial and typing occupation in 1880, by 1900 they accounted for 75 percent of all typists.
Rashid then looks at how the diffusion of the typewriter across counties affects women's labour force participation, marriage rates, and fertility. To estimate causal impacts, she makes use of a shift-share instrument that combines local industry employment shares measured in 1880 (prior to the adoption of the typewriter) with national shifts in the demand for typists between 1880 and 1920. The labour force participation, marriage, and fertility outcomes are all measured in 1920, and the key data she uses come from Census microdata. In terms of labour force participation, Rashid finds that:
...a 1 percentage point (pp) increase in the predicted change in the number of typists between 1880 and 1920 led to a 0.75 pp increase in share of women in the labor force in 1920. Using a back-of-the-envelope calculation, this estimate implies that without the shock of the typewriter, women’s labor force participation rate in 1920 would have been 3.65 pp lower, equivalent to nearly 1.16 million fewer women in the labor force out of a population of 31.7 million women of working age.
Next, Rashid shows that the effects were not just limited to White women, but there were increases in labour force participation among Black women as well. However, how those labour force changes manifested were quite different between White and Black women. Specifically:
...a 1 pp greater increase in the predicted change in typists had a 1.7 pp higher share of Black women in the labor force in 1920. I show that the main mechanism underlying this change is the reallocation of White women out of unpaid housework and into clerical employment, which increased the demand for Black women’s labor in paid household services work.
Turning to impacts on marriage and motherhood, Rashid finds that:
The labor market effects induced by the introduction of the typewriter further led to a 0.4 pp reduction in the share of women who were married and a 0.6 pp decrease in the share of women who had children in 1920. These estimates imply that the share of married women and women with children would have been 2.04 pp and 2.89 pp higher in 1920, equivalent to 650,000 additional married women and 920,000 additional women with children in the absence of the typewriter.
Importantly, these results relate to the proportion of women with children in 1920, rather than their completed fertility (the number of children they have over their lifetimes). The results could therefore reflect women delaying having children, rather than necessarily having fewer children overall. Nevertheless, what Rashid finds are large effects, and she shows that they are robust to various alternative choices or data sources. I particularly appreciated the use of corresponding data from Canada used to construct an alternative shift-share instrument, which alleviates concerns that there are unobserved time-variant changes at the county level that correlate with the shift-share instrument and might have been associated with the outcome variables.
The next part of the paper is particularly interesting. Rashid extends her analysis to look at social mobility, specifically, she tracks young white women from the 1920 to 1940 Census, looking at how the ranking of their husbands within the income distribution (in 1940) are related to the ranking of their fathers within the income distribution (in 1920), and how that relationship differs for women who are typists from other white women. She finds that:
For women who grew up at the 25th percentile of their father’s income distribution, working as a typist is associated with marrying men with an average income rank that was 18.4 percentiles above the average rank of husbands of non-typists. Importantly, this mobility advantage is not present in alternative white-collar occupations such as teaching, despite the fact that these occupations offered women similar wages.
Using the same shift-share instrument (SSIV) as for the previous analyses, Rashid then finds that:
...conditional on father’s socioeconomic status, women living in counties with a one percentage point greater increase in the predicted change in typists married husbands whose income rank was 1.27 percentiles higher. Among women with fathers at the 25th percentile, residing in a county with an above median value of the SSIV is associated with marrying men with an average income rank that was 4 percentiles higher
Importantly, again these results are robust to alternative methods and data. Importantly, Rashid also compares sisters within the same family, finding that the social mobility advantage of being a typist remains. The mechanism argued to underlie these results is that women working as typists were more able to work alongside men of higher income earning potential than women with a similar education level in other occupations. Rashid specifically contrasts the results with those for teachers, nurses, and telephone operators, finding that none of those other occupations offered the same social mobility advantage than that of typists.
Finally, Rashid draws some parallels in the conclusion between the technological changes brought on by the diffusion of the typewriter and those arising from generative AI. She notes that while there may be displacement effects as a result of new technology, there are also increased labour market opportunities, spillovers between different groups of workers, and social consequences as well. While it's unlikely that generative AI will have a similar effect on marriage and fertility given the baseline conditions are very different now than they were in the late 19th Century, it is difficult to anticipate what, if any, social changes may arise due to the diffusion of this new technology. The history of the typewriter is a useful reminder that the consequences of technological change can extend far beyond the workplace.
Incidentally, Rashid is on the economics job market this year, and according to her website this paper is currently at the second-round revise-and-resubmit stage at the prestigious American Economic Review.
[HT: Marginal Revolution]
No comments:
Post a Comment